Not every hire is made because a problem has been named.

Some are made because a board meeting ended with a question that felt like an expectation. Some because a competitor announced something similar. Some because an org chart, when shown to the right people at the right moment, needs to look a particular way.

These are not cynical decisions. They are human ones. The pressure to appear ready is real, and it arrives before the readiness does.

But there is a cost that comes quietly: in the months after the hire, when the executive discovers that the role they were brought in for does not yet exist in practice. No infrastructure. No mandate that matches the title. A team that does not know what to bring them.

The signal the hire sends lasts one board meeting. The disruption lasts considerably longer.

The question here is simple: why one organisation can produce the same vacancy twice, with no clearer answer the second time than the first?